Image default
Home » 10 Best Eye Makeup Removers in 2020
Eyes

10 Best Eye Makeup Removers in 2020

You use all your favorite makeup products and brands; you look amazing, and you feel sensational. But what is the second-best feeling after creating your favorite look? Surely, it has to be taking it all off again to reveal the beautiful, healthy skin underneath and getting into bed with a makeup-free, fresh, and hydrated face? But we all know there’s nothing worse than feeling like you’ve left some makeup behind, especially when it comes to eye makeup.

You don’t want to wake up, look in the mirror, and realize that you’ve somehow morphed into a new species of Panda overnight. You also don’t want your eyes to feel itchy, irritated, or heavy. We’ve put together some of the best eye makeup removers out there, and our reviews will help you find the best one for you. We’ll help you care for your precious skin and eyes.

View The Best Eye Makeup Remover Below

1. Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes

Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes come in a twin pack that contains 50 pre-moistened towelettes. They are a quick and convenient solution to banish all makeup, including pesky waterproof mascara. These handy packs can fit into a handbag or makeup bag, making them one of the best eye makeup removers for those on the go.

They are resealable and leave no residue behind, which means you won’t have to rinse your face after use. The super-soft towelettes sweep effortlessly across the face, removing all traces of eye makeup, oil, and dirt buildup. This is the best way to ensure you won’t irritate the skin around your sensitive eyes.

Pros:
+ Removes waterproof eye makeup
+ Towelettes are super soft
+ Doesn’t dry out too quick
+ Are wet enough to remove all eye makeup
+ No sticky or oily residue

Why We Like It – We liked these towelettes because they don’t leave any stickiness behind. They leave your skin feeling fresh, clean, and hydrated after each use, and you can just throw them away. This is one of the best ways to take eye makeup off. They won’t scratch or leave a feeling of soreness, unlike other wipes.


2. Lancome Bi-Facil Double Action Eye Makeup Remover

Lancome Bi-Facil Double Action Eye Makeup Remover

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

The Lancome Bi-Facil Double Action comes in a non-oily formula. The higher price range makes this one of our more premium eye makeup products. Just shake the bottle to activate this magic little potion. You can use this with your favorite face cloth or cotton pads to smooth over the sensitive skin around the eyes or even the whole face. This is a smooth liquid; it’s a perfect combination of oil and water, which melts away dirt and makeup build-up. There’s no harsh rubbing involved. It can be used all over the face and eyes with a cotton pad or cloth.

Pros:
+ Great for the environment as there are no wipes involved
+ Removes waterproof eye makeup
+ Shake activation
+ Leaves skin feeling hydrated
+ Kind to sensitive eyes

Why We Like It – This little potion turned out to be our favorite premium quality product. The slightly oilier formula melts away the most stubborn of waterproof mascara with ease. It’s one of the best for leaving your face feeling smooth, nourished, and super soft without any irritation. The same can’t be said for other eye makeup removers.


3. Maybelline Expert Eyes Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

Maybelline Expert Eyes Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Maybelline Expert Eyes Oil-Free Eye is a great alternative for those who don’t like too much oil on there face. This is at the lower end of the price range compared to the rest of the best eye makeup removers. It’s the best choice for anyone on a budget. This one takes a little longer to work than the others as it needs to be soaked onto a cotton ball or pad first. It’s then held onto the eye area to dissolve both normal makeup and waterproof eye makeup. The just wipe it away to remove any smudge.

Pros:
+ Great value for money
+ Non-oily formula
+ No residue left behind
+ Great for oily skins

Why We Like It – We liked these makeup removers because they’re the best value for money. Maybelline provides a light, non-greasy formula that dissolves eye makeup effectively but just with a little more time.


4. Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water

Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Next up is the Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water. Like it says on the bottle, it’s light and as natural as water. The non-perfumed or oily formula won’t sting or irritate the eyes. Like the Maybelline Expert Eyes, this needs to be soaked onto a cotton ball or pad and held on the eye to dissolve harsh waterproof mascara or eyeliner. It works a treat on the whole face to remove makeup and dirt build-up.

Pros:
+ Water like consistency
+ Great value for money
+ No oily residue left behind
+ Cleanses and hydrates the skin
+ Removes lipstick effectively

Why We Like It – We liked this Garnier SkinActive because it’s a very light solution. It gently wipes away makeup and lipstick, effectively leaving skin smooth and hydrated without any residue or tightness on the skin. In fact, we think it might be the best makeup remover for removing lipstick on this list. It’s also good value for money.


5. CeraVe Micellar Water

CeraVe Micellar Water

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Number five on our list is the CeraVe Micellar Water. This three-in-one formula is perfect for not only removing eye makeup and all over face makeup, but it also hydrates the skin and helps to restore the skin’s natural protective barrier.

It’s gentle enough to use day and night and is non-comedogenic, which means it won’t clog up pores in the process. It’s non-drying and doesn’t contain any harsh chemicals and parabens that will leave your skin feeling heavy or tight.

Pros:
+ 3 in 1 formula
+ Contains no parabens
+ Gentle enough to use twice a day
+ Won’t clog pores
+ Is non-drying

Why We Like It – We liked this product because it doesn’t contain any harsh chemicals. It’s super kind and has three functions to keep skin protected and cared for, as well as removing makeup and impurities. This won’t leave a tight feeling, even if you use it more than once a day.


6. Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Neutrogena is another shake activation product. Its gentle, non-greasy formula sweeps away stubborn waterproof mascara and eyeliner, banishing dirt and daily build-up. It’s kind enough on sensitive eyes even for contact lens wearers. It may need a rinse after use to remove any residue for those who aren’t keen on the after-feel.

Pros:
+ Clever shake activation
+ Gentle for contact lens wearers
+ Non-greasy formula
+ Non-Perfumed
+ Good for the sensitive eye area

Why We Like It – We liked this because it’s ophthalmologist-tested, which means it’s safe for those who wear contact lenses. It removes makeup without irritating sensitive eyes. The shake activation formula means it’s a perfect combination of removing power and skin hydration.


7. Bioderma Sensibio Soothing Micellar Cleansing Water

Bioderma Sensibio Soothing Micellar Cleansing Water

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Next up is the Bioderma Sensibio Soothing Micellar Cleansing Water. This is another gentle water-like solution that’s similar to the CeraVe Micellar Water. It’s close to the skin’s natural composites and is specially formulated for more irritated complexions. It instantly gives a soothing feel to an irritated face, as well as providing a fresh, cleansed feeling.

Pros:
+ Non-rince
+ Fragrance-free
+ Soothes irritated and sensitive skin
+ Removes waterproof makeup
+ Paraben-free

Why We Like It – We liked this gentle formula because it’s aimed more towards people who have more sensitivity. It’s ultra-gentle and fragrance-free, which is kind to sensitive eyes and lips while soothing irritated areas. This makes it perfect for those prone to breakouts.


8. Cetaphil Gentle Waterproof Makeup Remover

Cetaphil Gentle Waterproof Makeup Remover

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Next in line is the Cetaphil Gentle Waterproof Makeup Remover. This is another shake-to-activate solution that’s gentle enough to use on sensitive eyes and skin. Use this non-greasy solution on a cotton pad. It will leave a refreshing feeling with added aloe vera and botanicals, green tea, and ginseng to give you that wide-awake feeling. Again, like the CeraVe Micellar Water, this is non-comedogenic, so it won’t clog pores or leave skin feeling heavy.

Pros:
+ Removes waterproof mascara
+ Shake activation
+ Gentle to sensitive skin and eyes
+ Has added aloe vera and skin botanicals with green tea and ginseng
+ Non-comedogenic

Why We Like It – We liked this one because it’s the only one on our list to contain botanicals and aloe vera extracts, as well as ginseng, which instantly refreshes the whole face and skin, making you feel super clean and refreshed.


9. Covergirl Clean Makeup Remover

Covergirl Clean Makeup Remover

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Number nine is the Covergirl Makeup Remover. It comes as a lightweight formula that gently but thoroughly removes eye and lip makeup, including waterproof mascara and eyeliner. It can be used on a damp cotton pad or a face sponge. It’s aluminum-free, cruelty-free and is light enough to use on combination skins. It leaves your face feeling fresh and hydrated, as well as moisturized and clean. There’s also very little oily residue.

Pros:
+ Lightweight lotion
+ Cruelty-free
+ Light enough for combination skin
+ Aluminium free
+ Gentle on skin around eyes and lips

Why We Like It – We really liked this popular choice. Its super lightweight lotion-type formula is kind to the sensitive eye area and removes even the toughest waterproof mascara while caring for the eyes.


10. Simple Kind To Skin Eye Makeup Remover

Simple Kind To Skin Eye Makeup Remover

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON →

Lastly, we have the Simple Kind To Skin Eye Makeup Remover. Simple is known for keeping their products free from perfumes and harsh chemicals – the same applies to there remover. This ‘water-like’ solution is clear in color and watery in consistency. It works on waterproof mascara and actually helps to nourish lashes after each use. Another shake activation formula leaves face hydrated with no sticky residue.

Pros:
+ No harsh chemicals
+ Nourishes lashes
+ Kind to sensitive areas
+ No sticky residue
+ No strong fragrance

Why We Like It – We liked Simple Kind To Skin Eye Makeup Remover, not only for its effective makeup removing powers but also for its added ‘lash nourishing’ feature. This is something that’s not advertised with the other makeup removers. It’s kind to the whole face and eye area.


Eye Makeup Removers Buyer’s Guide

So you have read our 10 Best Eye makeup removers. Now you know they all have the same function but multiple benefits to suit different needs. But how do we actually know which eye makeup remover is the best for us? Well, when looking for the perfect eye makeup remover to suit you, you will need to first determine what type of skin you have.

Girl Using Makeup Cleaner

Is it dry, or do you have more oily skin? Do you think your skin is a combination of different types? It’s also worth thinking about if you are sensitive, prone to breakouts, blackheads, or irritation. Do you wear contact lenses, or do you have sensitive eyes?

Once you have thought about these different factors, you’ll want to choose a makeup remover that’s going to suit your skin type and needs. If your skin is oily, the best remover for you will be something that’s free from oil. You’ll also want a product that doesn’t need too much vigorous rubbing to avoid a stimulation in sebum production. For those of you who tend to feel dryer patches of skin or tightness after cleansing, oilier cleansers will work wonders for you.

Even ones with a slight residue may help with any tight feeling you may experience. If you are sensitive or prone to breakouts, you will always need something that’s soothing and labeled for sensitive skin. You should always avoid harsh chemicals and perfumed products.

Next, you need to decide what you want your eye makeup remover to achieve. Of course, we all want a full removal of products with no panda eyes, but do we want one that’s going to nourish our skin at the same time, or do we want a makeup remover that will be soothing? Do we want one that may leave a slight residue or not? A towelette or lotion with cotton pads? One that is vegan and cruelty-free? One that doesn’t have harsh chemicals? One that has added botanicals or one that doesn’t clog pores? Let us help!

We all want to go bed feeling fresh and clean, with no stingy eyes or cloudy vision. We don’t want to wake up with makeup on the pillowcase. Face wipes or pre-moistened towelettes are some of the most popular methods to remove makeup. They are convenient and can be used anywhere, anytime, and on the go. With little effort, they sweep away a full face of makeup in seconds. The ‘shake to activate’ formulas are some of the best and most effective.

Woman with cotton pads

Their dual action of both water and oil-based formulas are best to melt away makeup, leaving your skin feeling soft without that awful tight feeling that micellar water or another water-based option may leave. Dry skin is especially prone to this. The shake activation makeup remover is the best at banishing pesky waterproof mascara and eyeliners better than any other. These, however, may leave a slight oily residue, which some people may not like, especially contact lens wearers. This can be swept away with a cotton pad or cloth and a water-based makeup remover or just a quick rinse.

We also want an eye makeup remover that is not only kind to our skin but is kind to our pocket. You’ll want to choose a product that’s suitable for your budget. If you’re going to choose from the more expensive range, make sure they’re using less and lasting you a long time.

In conclusion, out of all of the ten products that we reviewed, we found that the Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes was the best eye makeup remover overall. It’s the best for busy women and moms – it can be taken anywhere and used anytime. The pre-moistened towelettes won’t dry out after opening, unlike some other wipes on the market. They don’t sting your eyes, and they won’t leave any sticky residue behind. They leave a fresh, cleansed, and hydrated face.

Lancome Bi-Facil Double Action Eye Makeup Remover is the best makeup remover for premium quality. This magical little potion is definitely worth the price tag. Its shake activation formula melts away and dissolves even the toughest of waterproof mascaras and eyeliners. This doesn’t take a whole load of rubbing in the process. There’s very little effort required. It’s super gentle for the whole face and leaves you feeling hydrated and nourished.

Woman removing makeup

Maybelline Expert Eyes Oil-Free is one of our favorites for great value. It may need a little more time and effort to work, but it’s still very effective out of all the makeup removers.

All of the makeup removers in our list do the job they are intended to do, but they vary in other features and benefits. They will fit different people with different skins, lifestyles, and budgets. Some of them dissolve makeup in an instant, and some take a little more time and effort to work. Some of them are a wipe, and some a lotion. Some are oil-based, while others are oil-free.

None of us want panda eyes, a tight after-feel, or for a makeup remover to irritate or sting our eyes. Here’s to choosing the perfect potion for you! The best remover will leave your skin feeling fresh, clean, makeup-free, and ready for the next makeup application.

Related posts

10 Best Eye Cream for Wrinkles in 2020

Heidi Garrett

10 Best Eyebrow Growth Serums in 2020

Heidi Garrett

10 Best Eyeshadow Primers in 2020

Heidi Garrett

9 Best Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes in 2020

Heidi Garrett

10 Best Pencil Eyeliners in 2020

Heidi Garrett

10 Best Brow Gels in 2020

Heidi Garrett