Image default
Home » 9 Best Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes in 2020

9 Best Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes in 2022

Raw, watery eyes that won’t stop itching is enough of a nuisance to swear off all mascaras forever! Your eyes are naturally sensitive, often needing extra TLC. Let’s face it, we are all guilty of neglecting a proper cleanse occasionally. We’ve all furiously scrubbed at clumpy, tangled lashes the next day, losing a number of them in the process.

That’s bad enough, but for those suffering from allergies, it’s an unending Russian roulette as you try and guess which ingredient will or won’t cause misery. Help is here. We have some of the best mascaras for sensitive skin, which keep you bright-eyed without worry.

View The Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes Below

1. L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara

L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara


Available in a range of different colors, and full of lash conditioning ingredients, L’Oreal’s Voluminous Original Mascara is one of the best mascaras for sensitive eyes around. Not only do your eyelashes feel supple and hydrated, but this mascara can also be removed easily using just soap and water. No more scrubbing sensitive skin!

The formula makes an impact, increasing the volume of your natural lashes x 5, and the applicator prevents clumping by sweeping the buildable product onto each lash individually. Better still, this mascara is compatible with sensitive eyes and those of you who wear contact lenses. It even has a waterproof version too.

+ Easily washes off with soap and water
+ Conditioners keeps lashes soft and cared for
+ Lashes look five times fuller

Why We Like It – This is one of the best mascaras for sensitive eyes, giving you all the benefits of bold, amplified lashes without irritation. If you like this product, another boosting mascara to try is Tarte’s Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara. As the name suggests, lights, camera, lashes deliver your lashes 4-in-1 mascara benefits, including conditioning, building volume, curling, and lengthening.

2. Eyeko Lash Alert Mascara

Eyeko Lash Alert Mascara


Parabens. A classic trigger for people with sensitive skin, and one to be especially cautious of when you suffer allergic reactions. Fortunately, Eyeko has revealed their paraben-free Lash Alert Mascara, one which is perfect for sensitive eyes!

Packed with natural botanical ingredients and protective protein Keratin, this premium quality mascara enriches lashes by targeting them from the inside to strengthen. At the same time, the curved brush provides a 90-degree angle definition for care and high impact.

+ Paraben-free formula
+ Fibre-enhanced for fuller lashes
+ Keratin, shea butter and much more to condition

Why We Liked It – Lash Alert not only provides volume and length, but the proteins and Shea butter prevent flakiness and crumbling to stop irritation from fallout on the skin.

3. Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Washable Mascara

Tag Heuer Aquaracer Watch


It’s easy to forget that, along with sensitive eyes, comes the rubbing. And with the rubbing, comes the devastating side effect of lash loss. We all want healthy, youthful-looking lashes, and the Full ‘N Soft Washable Mascara by Maybelline does its best to navigate these problems.

The hypoallergenic and ophthalmologist-tested mascara contains Vitamin E to moisturize and thicken existing lashes, so eyes are protected. The ‘Quick Dissolve’ formula ensures minimal damage to lashes when removing it.

+ Hypoallergenic mascara
+ Suitable for contact lens wearers
+ Quick Dissolve technology

Why We Like It – This is a great value product and a whole host of benefits for sensitive eyes. This mascara is looking out for your lashes by keeping them silky and infusing with conditioner. Brittle lashes, be gone!

4. NaturLash Mineral Mascara

NaturLash Mineral Mascara


This is the best for super sensitive eyes and natural beauty lovers alike, NaturLash Mineral Mascara is best described by what it doesn’t contain. The 99% natural mascara is free from parabens, gluten, mercury, toxins, is vegan, and cruelty-free too. Created for people with eye sensitivities and contact lens wearers, the hypoallergenic products help to prevent lash fallout and are effortlessly removed with water.

+ Made without toxic chemicals
+ Vegan and cruelty-free
+ Hypoallergenic, tear-free formula

Why We Like It – Thicker, longer lashes with no nasties, this mascara for sensitive eyes can also be used as eyeliner. Dip a fine angled brush into the tube and use it as normal for a double hit of natural goodness.

5. Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara and Lash Primer

Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara and Lash Primer


Honest Beauty from Jessica Alba is another must-have brand for products without potential allergens, such as paraffin, silicones, and mineral oils that can clog pores. Their dual-ended Extreme Length Mascara and Lash Primer deliver both a lash primer to even and intensify color and a dermatologist-tested mascara safe for sensitive eyes. Jojoba Esters, an emollient comparable to our skin’s oils, gives added suppleness to lashes naturally.

+ 2-in-1 primer and mascara
+ Suitable for contact lens wearers
+ Cruelty-free

Why We Like It – A mascara and primer in one make this product a makeup marvel. The primer ensures that your lashes look extra long and fluttery, while the mascara prevents common irritants from harming your eyes.

6. Clinique High Impact Mascara

Clinique High Impact Mascara


Synonymous with reliable, skin-kind products, Clinique is, of course, on our list. As a firm favorite with customers, the High Impact Mascara delivers multiple benefits with lash thickening mascara and a brush separating and preventing clumps. This mascara works on all skin types, including sensitive, so your eyes will have all the impact you need with just a few sweeps of a brush.

+ Thickens and lengthens
+ Brush designed to separate lashes
+ Kind to eyes

7. EASY ON THE EYES Sensitive Eye Mascara

EASY ON THE EYES Sensitive Eye Mascara


Formulated with sensitive souls in mind, EASY ON THE EYES Sensitive Eye Mascara is smudge-proof and fragrance-free mascara designed for long-lasting, comfortable wear. The natural waxes and clay that make up the mascara help to soften lashes, making them less likely to crumble or flake.

Better still, the specially created brush ensures that the maximum product is swept on every single lash with no dragging or clumping. Quick to cleanse off, the wax dissolves easily with warm water and soap. It’s great for busy (or lazy) days.

+ Gentle and natural mascara
+ Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact wearers
+ Unique brush coats all your lashes

Why We Like It – This is a perfect everyday lash mascara. It’s gentle, buildable, and magnifies volume. Available in black, brown and navy, these mascaras are rich in pigment, yet wash away without pulling or scrubbing your lashes.

8. COVERGIRL Professional Remarkable Mascara

COVERGIRL Professional Remarkable Mascara


A great mascara stays put until you decide otherwise and this Professional Remarkable Mascara from COVERGIRL, boasts lasting waterproof protection and maximum color impact. This mascara is also suited to sensitive skin, and if you do wipe your eyes – not that you’ll need to – the product will not smudge or streak. Gentle cleansing removes all trace, making this still one of our all-time favorite mascaras.

+ Washes off easily with soap and water
+ Waterproof
+ Rich color mascaras

Why We Like It – Familiar and affordable, the Professional Remarkable Mascara gives eyes beautiful length and definition, as well as protection from unsightly smudges.

9. Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara

Burt's Bees 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara


Nature-loving fans everywhere will be thrilled with this 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara. Made without parabens, phthalates, or SLS (sodium lauryl sulfate – the science behind the foam in your cosmetics), these mascaras strengthen lashes from root to tip, keeping eyes looking youthful.

Jojoba oil and glycerin (an emollient derived from plant sources), permeates and protects eyes without aggravating the skin. There are so many benefits. It’s approved by ophthalmologists and made without synthetic fragrances. And, of course, it’s not tested on animals.

+ 100% natural lash mascara
+ Suited for all eyes
+ Ophthalmologist-tested and safe for contact lens wearers

Why We Like It – As well as being one of the most natural mascaras on our list, it’s the most universal, with it’s black/brown color that everyone can wear, framing eyes beautifully.

Mascara for Sensitive Eyes Buyer’s Guide

There are a few dos and don’ts when looking for mascaras that won’t harm your eyes. But before you get too in-depth with chemicals and toxins, make sure you are first of all looking at the texture of your product. Sure, fiber-enhanced formulas are brilliant at extending your lashes for a dramatic eye, and tubing products are so useful for waterproofing, but these are two mechanical irritants that, when they flake off, can get trapped in the eye or behind your contact lens. Ouch.


Talking of ‘mechanical’ abrasions, check to see how you remove the mascara. Does it dissolve simply in warm water and soap, or will you be aggressively scrubbing at your poor face for ages? Repetitive dragging of the skin around the eye is not only going to make them instantly sore but can also speed up the aging process, so treat your eyes gently!

If you have stubborn mascara, hold your cleanser on a cotton pad on your eye for a minute or so to allow it to work before carefully removing in soft strokes. This prevents eyelashes from falling out prematurely. Next, look for any mascaras which are hypoallergenic (to reduce the risk of a reaction occurring) and ophthalmologist-tested (to further reassure that the product has been tested explicitly around the eye area.)

Woman applying black mascara on eyelashes with makeup brush

The real key to protecting yourself is definitely to keep it simple! We’ve reviewed some great brands above with mascaras packed with natural waxes, plant-derived moisturizers, and little else (meaning no long list of unpronounceable chemicals). As the trend for Vegan living continues, natural products will be more available for everyone.

Related posts

10 Best Eye Makeup Removers in 2022

Heidi Garrett

10 Best Brow Gels in 2022

Heidi Garrett

10 Best Eye Cream for Wrinkles in 2022

Heidi Garrett

10 Best Pencil Eyeliners in 2022

Heidi Garrett

How to Apply Eyeshadow (Fox Eye, Classic, and Highlight)

Heidi Garrett

10 Best Eyebrow Growth Serums in 2022

Heidi Garrett